Get step by step tips for using Rustoleum’s Chalked Paint to paint a marble fireplace surround.

How to make over a builder'grade fireplace with an upgraded mantel by | #fireplacemantel #updatedmantel #fireplacemakeover #mantelupgrade

When we purchased our home in 2005, there weren’t a lot of options for customizing our gas fireplace. You can read about how we upgraded the mantel here:

We chose a cream marble surround that worked perfectly with the warm colors that were popular that decade. But ever since we painted our downstairs Revere Pewter the cream surround has looked off.

My husband and I have been talking about what to do about the surround for about three years now. We’ve considered completely removing the marble, adding a hearth, raising the firebox, and doing a completely new surround. But since the money tree in the back yard has yet to start producing Benjamins, that wasn’t going to be happening any time soon!  🤣

We also researched covering the marble with tile. But we were nervous about doing tile ourselves for the very first time on something so prominent.

After some more researching, I stumbled across the idea to paint a marble fireplace surround. My curiosity was piqued! First, it would only cost about $25 in supplies (counting tape and a new paintbrush)! Second, it would be easy enough to do ourselves. And third, if we didn’t like it we’d only be out $25.

How to paint a marble fireplace surround with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY

Before making the decision to paint the surround I tested out how it would look! A little black cardstock and tape were all it took to help us see that it would look great.

How to Paint a Marble Fireplace Surround

Have you ever heard of chalk paint? This stuff is some kind of wonderful, miracle-working paint! It was developed by Annie Sloan for furniture refinishing and distressing. It’s very thick, has a matte finish, and it adheres to most anything!

I decided to use Rustoleum’s Chalked Paint because I wanted to be able to seal it with a protective top coat. It also can withstand the heat from a fireplace. 😎

How to paint a marble fireplace surround with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY

I selected Rustoleum’s Charcoal Chalked Paint because I knew a black surround would provide a truly neutral palette for any decor. I ordered it from Amazon because I’m an Amazon-Prime-a-holic. Me and my UPS man are tight. 🤣

Supplies to Paint Your Fireplace Surround:

Step 1: Prepare the marble

One of the best parts of chalky paints is they adhere really well to just about any surface. Primer is never necessary! And while sanding is generally not required with chalky paints it will improve adhesion.

How to give your marble fireplace surround a makeover with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY

As you can see, the marble was polished to a high gloss. It was really simple to rough up the surface with 100 grit sand paper.

How to give your marble fireplace surround a makeover with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #DIY #simple

See the difference?

I used a wet sponge to clean up all the marble dust. Then went over it with a tack cloth to remove any residue.

Step 2: Tape your Edges

I used Frogtape to protect the wood mantle and the carpet. And then a drop cloth for the carpet too. I’m not the neatest of painters… 😉

How to paint a marble fireplace surround with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble

Step 3: Paint the Marble Surround

The Chalked paint is very thick, and it dries very quickly. You’re going to want to use a stir stick to get the pigment thoroughly mixed into the paint. Shaking just doesn’t do the trick since it’s so thick.

How to paint a marble fireplace surround with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble

Because it dries quickly, you’ll want to work quickly. I didn’t mind if some brush strokes were visible because I felt like they could provide some texture to make the surface look somewhat like slate. But if brush strokes bother you, you can use a foam roller instead.

Y’all? I was SO NERVOUS! But as soon as I painted the first little part of the marble surround, I was in LOVE! I’m talking major heart eyes!! It looked SO GOOD!

I started with the top section and did short horizontal strokes to cover the surface. Then ran the paintbrush lightly over the surface from one end to the next to make the strokes look even.

Next, I painted the two side sections with vertical strokes using the same technique.

I finished with the marble on the floor. I could NOT believe what a difference it made! Buh-bye, cream marble, helllllooooo black beauty! 😍

How to paint a marble fireplace surround with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY

After the first coat, you can see there were some spots that needed a bit more coverage. I let it dry for an hour, then went back to do a second coat. It probably wasn’t necessary to wait that long because this paint dries SUPER QUICKLY.

Then I removed the tape right after I finished the second coat. I didn’t want to risk the paint possibly peeling!

Step 4: Seal the Chalked Paint

Before you seal the surround, make sure you clean the surface. You don’t want any stray hairs, dust or lint getting sealed in!

Make sure you stir the topcoat sealer. I was amazed at how much the consistency changed from stirring it! I applied the sealer using the same process that I used for the paint.

How to give your marble fireplace surround a makeover with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY

It isn’t nearly as thick as the chalked paint. It goes on looking gray, but it dries to a completely clear matte finish.

I applied three coats of the sealer, letting it dry for a full day between each coat. I wanted to make sure my beautiful new surface was well-protected!

And that’s it!

How to give your marble fireplace surround a makeover with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY

I only used about 1/4 of a can of the paint and 1/4 of a can of the sealer for this project, which means I’ve got a beautiful new fireplace surround for less than $10!


Everyone loves a good before and after, so let’s take a look back at where we started before upgrading the mantel and painting the marble surround:

How to make over a builder'grade fireplace with an upgraded mantel by | #fireplacemantel #updatedmantel #fireplacemakeover #mantelupgrade

And here it is now!

How to give your marble fireplace surround a makeover with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY

So if you have an outdated marble surround on your fireplace, this technique is an inexpensive and simple option to give it a facelift. What do you think? I’d love to hear from you in the comments!

Pin it to Remember it:

How to paint a marble fireplace surround with chalk paint by | #chalkpaint #chalkedpaint #fireplacesurround #paintedmarble #fireplacemakeover #paintingmarble #simple #DIY


22 Comments on How to Paint a Marble Fireplace Surround | Fireplace Makeover Part 2

  1. Can I use the foam roller with the top coat as the 1st coat I used a paint brush and I don’t like the brush marks. I really liked the matte finish of the chalk paint. I wish I had not did the top coat.
    It does look 100 times better than the green marble!!!

    • Hey Judy! You should definitely be able to use the foam roller for your top coat! Maybe give it a light sanding with fine-grit sandpaper to remove any brush strokes, wipe away any dust and let it dry, and then do the top coat with the foam roller. Be sure to just do a thin layer. I’m so glad it worked for you! I love mine so much. 🙂

  2. Looks beautiful! Our fireplace surround looks exactly like yours before Your makeover. You’ve inspired me and given me hope. How well does the paint hold up to heat? We use our gas fireplace all winter.

    • Thank you! I was so nervous to try it but figured it would be an inexpensive option to try first before making a pricier fix. I did research beforehand and the Chalked brand by Rustoleum is supposed to hold up to the heat. We use our fireplace a lot at my house during the winter months and the finish hasn’t shown any signs of being affected so far! We used it for about 1.5 months nearly every day after doing the paint job. Hope that helps!

  3. I painted our fireplace this weekend after finding your pin. I am so happy how it has turned out. I agree that it does look like slate now. Thanks for sharing.

  4. My fireplace looks exactly the way yours used to look and I want to paint mine as well! Is the Charcoal color black or does it have a slate gray look to it? Thank you!

    • Hey Brittney! I would consider the charcoal to be black, although when the sun is shining directly on it through my front door, it can read a little more very dark gray. It is seriously the best project I’ve done in my home this year! I’m so excited to share Christmas pictures with it looking this way. If you go to our Instagram account (@simply2moms), you can see some more photos of how it looks now. Hope that helps!!

  5. It looks fabulous. I would like to do a kind of translucent gold wash or glaze over my marble surround. Do you know of any product I could use to do that? I’d like something more like a stain or glaze so the marble shows through but I can change the color.

    • Thanks so much, Sheryl! From what I understand, you can water down chalk paint and wipe it off for a more translucent look. That technique allows the wood grain to show through, so it sounds like it may work to let the marble pattern show too? But I’d recommend trying it on a sample tile first before doing it to the fireplace surround. Good luck! Let me know how it goes!

  6. For those who have enjoyed your painted marble god sometime now: has it endured over time with no scratches. I have toddler grands that like to move things over my hearth.

  7. We followed your steps and are thrilled with the results. We did sand the tile first and use a cleaner before painting. In our case we painted over gross red porcelain tile.

    • I am so excited to hear you had great results! I’m happy to report too that after a year of use, the paint is holding up beautifully on mine. I use the fireplace all the time, and also have a metal grate that has been scraped on the floor section several times and there are no chips or scratches. Here’s to making our homes suit our styles for a reasonable price!

  8. Hello,

    I followed your steps and love the results! But, as I was applying the top coat, I scratched across the paint with my nail and it chipped. I have to repair it and apply top coat, but I am concerned that it will chip this easily even after the top coat cures. I gave pets, with nails. Any additional suggestions? Thanks!

    • Hi Tanya! I think the problem is that the paint is designed for you to distress it which is why it chipped before the top coat had cured. I’ve had mine done for over a year now, and am happy to report it still looks great with no chips or scratches. I have a metal screen that sits on the floor that the kids (and I!) have knocked over and scraped across the surface. I thought for sure it would show, but it’s held up great! The top coat really does seal and protect it. I would recommend applying several coats for added protection, allowing it to cure for a full day between coats. I’d love to see a before/after pic! You can email it to us if you’d like to share!

  9. Hi thank you for posting your idea. My husband and I have a fireplace exactly like this except it is gas. The marble now looks yelow or off white due to painting the mantle white. The marble on top of the fireplace stone/marble gets really really hot. So hot you cant touch it. Will that still be safe to paint?

    • Hey Kayla! My fireplace is also a gas fireplace. While I know the surround does get hot when it’s on, I’ve never noticed it getting so hot that it can’t be touched, so our fireplace boxes may be different? When I was researching doing this project, the Chalked paint by Rustoleum was listed as being safe to use on fireplace surrounds. It’s been painted for over a year now, and it’s not showing any signs of chipping, scratching or peeling from the heat. However, my husband and I knew that we were going to replace the marble altogether if this fix didn’t work out for us, so it was a safe bet for us to experiment and try it. I hope that helps you with deciding whether you’d like to give it a try?

  10. Painted my marble fireplace surround with 4 coats of charcoal and have only applied 1 coat of matte topcoat (using the same paints you did in this post) Anyway after the first coat of sealant had been applied even after drying it looks splotchy Do you know what happened and how I can fix it? Thanks!

    • Hey Becky! I’m sorry to hear your surround is looking splotchy after applying the sealant. What kind of a brush did you use? I’ve been doing some research about it and it looks like that could be because it dried unevenly? It’s important to work in small sections. If it’s still looking splotchy, I would recommend contacting Rustoleum to see if they have recommendations about what to do. I hope that helps!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *